Gloria Steinem can pog mo thoin!!!
Feminism is a big lie. There, I said it. It’s out. I have hesitated to write this post for a while, even though it has been rattling around my head. My hesitation is based on the fact that I have no intention of making this blog a forum for anything else than light social commentary, random thoughts, a little gossip and bitching here and there, keeping the writing wheel greased with my daily 500 words and all that other bloggy goodness.
But I am so annoyed, so let down by the whole “promise to women” and “women’s equality” and all that shite, I need to let it out. I know I am going to piss a lot of people off by this post, but so be it. Hear me out before you comment.
Who wins the
Caught between the Pre and the Post Feminist Era This is another sore point or me. Feminism has seen more women in the workforce which you would think would be a good thing from my feminine point of view, right? Wrong! There are women who have no interest in having a career but find themselves in the new post-feminist society which has told them they are scum if they have no ambition in the business world. They find themselves in situations that are wholly unfulfilling but they have to support themselves – remember, no marriage, no male “bread-winner”? You are a backward idiot if your only ambition is to keep a home and raise children so go out there and break your back for just over minimum wage. And you better pull your weight because you ain’t getting married anytime soon.
People, you know these poor women who are caught in between the pre and post feminist world. They work because they are supposed and leave their children in day care even though it kills them. Go past a receptionist or the HR department. Look the framed pictures of children on desks, look at the women with candy on their desk, who make sure they bring in a cake for a birthday on the floor. These women don’t want careers. Real career women will not do those kinds of things. Real career women can't do these things and continue to be taken seriously. At least, that is the thought. So even if I wanted to give into that italian woman instinct of mine to feed everyone, I would never bring in brownies to a business meeting. Not if I really wanted them to listen to me.
But why am I annoyed by these women, even though I do feel for them? Because when they are weak, the women in the office, the ones that sharpen their talons to do battle with grey suits, day after day, suffer. I was told once in a salary review that I was “too aggressive”. If you think that a man would get that kind of feedback, you are totally deluded. It is my job to be aggressive. I am strategist in one of the largest companies on the planet. It is my job to get people to listen to me. Too aggressive? Hmmmm. Men bosses would rather have the candy-offering, birthday-remembering, fuzzy-pencil, flower mug, babies on their PC wallpaper women in the office. They don’t have arguments about salary with these women.
The phenomenon of maternity leave. I have been covering for 2 women on maternity leave for the past YEAR! In
I am not suggesting that becoming a mother is not work! It certainly is and should be treated like a full time job with benefits and entitlements like every other job in the world but tell me how come I am doing the work of 3 people and I don’t get the chance to garner the same benefits. Oh, and I have to do the late nights, all the travelling and the weekends because I don’t have a family. When am I going to have a social life which will lead to me getting pregnant because I sure don’t have one now!!! Also, what if I were sterile? Could I take a maternity leave and “give birth” to a novel.
This is another bi-product of feminism. It has pitted woman against woman who, for whatever reason, have found themselves leading different lives. It has made us competitive with each other, and no longer just for men, for everything – job, money, status, power. It has told us our natural instinct and biological tendencies are old-fashioned and should be suppressed. It has allowed men to get out of once was a shared responsibility to children and for what? The women who wanted careers over family could have had that in the 1950’s. Many, many did. Was it an uphill climb? Sure but it still is! I am not getting paid as much as the men who are doing the same job as me and I can’t win because if I point this out, if I demand it, I am “too aggressive”. As far as I can see, absolutely nothing has gotten easier.
Good with the Bad. Don’t get me wrong – I am in no hurry to get married and have a family. I like being independent and successful. I am glad I own my own house and car, etc. and I certainly do not begrudge maternity leave, even long ones, but I am unhappy about this social engineering that went on without my consent. I am unhappy when I have to contend with a social order which doesn’t feel natural. I don’t feel “empowered”. I do feel stressed, over-tired and lonely sometimes.
I guess mine is the new face of feminism.
13 Comments:
Wow, this a really tremendous and intelligently-written post. I can't say I am in a position to comment on it at all, but I can say it was very well-written.
- D.
Dim - just because you are a man doesn't mean you cannot have an opinion about feminism. I have an opinion on just about everything, whether or not I am in the position to have one or not ;-)
pog, to be honest, i'm not sure what point you were arguing.
failures in the workplace to recognize and reward women equally are failures of the company and failures of the men making the decisions, not of feminism. in my company there are many women executives, and while i don't know their salaries in relation to men, they are doing well for themselves. and they're managing children as well.
when a couple, or a man, or a woman, decides to have children, then SOMEONE should be home taking care of the children. i don't care if it's the woman, OR the man, someone's got to be there. people forget when they decide to have a kid that you're committing to raising a child in the best and safest manner possible for the next 18 years. if you can't afford it, then don't have a kid. having a kid isn't something you do because everyone's doing it, it's something you do because you have the means and commitment to do it.
also, i've seen plenty of women out there pack a bag and never look back. and i've seen guys caring for children on their own, and guys working three jobs to support their ex-wife and kids.
we formed certain functions in the past to help ensure the survival of ourselves as a species. men hunted because they were generally larger and made more effective hunters. women cared for hearth and home and kid because they were so constituted to do so.
feminism is an attempt to put women on an equal footing in this modern world, but it's not going to be an easy solution going against millions of years of evolution.
I think modern feminism is about having the opportunity to make your own choices in life. I can be anything I want. I think that housewives are getting more respect as we learn more about the benefits of having a parent in the home at all times.
Pog, let's recap something you said recently:
- I am worried that I am in my mid-thirties and I am not yet married (70%)
- I am worried that I do not have any discernible maternal instinct outside of dog ownership and I an nearing my infertile years (75%)
I believe things will happen when they are supposed to happen. But I don't know how go from worrying about this one day...to this post..
Hormones possibly. I blame that on every crazy thought I have..
ha, I guess a feminist would blame it on society!
hmmm...
I'm with Dim on this one.
Very well written but i also don't feel that I'm in a postition to comment.
I guess I could say that ISMs in general are not my cup of tea.
The biggest drawback to Feminism is the idea that woman are equal to men in all areas... That's bullshit. There are certain jobs Women have no business doing.
As an example, I don't want a woman firefighter trying to pull my 200 pound frame from a burning building.
There are others...
I will say I would rather work for a man than a woman. Hands down, every time! Every women I've ever worked for has been a underqualified trainwreck. One that had no business being in that position she was in and would never be allowed to mantain that position if she were a man.
I'm not saying there aren't wonderful, qualified women out there running companies all over the world.... I just haven't had the experience of working for one.
My views make feminists weep. While I do relish the idea of being independent and making my own decisions, I would be very happy letting my man go to work while I take care of the house or only work part-time. My mom was a housewife so I feel that it's important to have one parent at home, and usually women are better at that sort of thing.
I've known some women who were ball-busters and succeeded in the business world, but I wouldn't want, for example, a female president. Women are too emotional and hormonal and make decisions with their hearts instead of their heads a lot of times.
I don't like the double standard where women are seen as being too aggressive for doing the same things men do though.
oh yes and more thing...I recently got a flat tire. That's no job for a woman! EVER!
My brother in law swooped in like a hero and changed my tire on the spot. I was so happy. He said he'd drive my home and said "here take my keys and drive my car". I questioned him and said "why can I drive mine now you just changed the tire?"
he said " don't question it, drive my car, its what us men need to do, I'll drive yours home".
"I got it. Ok."
I didn't oppose and felt protected.
not even sure if this fits into what we're all saying..
I just don't ever want to change my own tire.
Jenny,
Pretty sure "using your head" isn't required for the President these days....
:-)
Sage - you work in la la land. I know, I worked there myself. You and the women that work there are very lucky, it is totally and utterly geared to support a family unit - actually if you are single there, you are at more of a disadvantage but, and please don't take this the wrong way (any of you!) it is not a true representation of how most companies work (the amount I have worked for is nearing double digits). And should other companies adopt your companies ethos? Maybe, but ultimately that flexibility given to the "care provider" is going to cost career opportunities. Even where you are.
And while I take your point about it being the failure of male management to reward good women, you get branded a "feminist" in any place of work, and you have one strike against you. There is something wrong there - whether feminists need a good PR firm, I am not sure, but when porn stars and strippers are the biggest fans of feminist ethos in today's society - something is wrong with that ethos.
Fresh - my point is, we (us women) have been told we can be anything we want. Biology, evolution, society, tells us different. That is where the big lie comes in. It's like when they tell every American school kid that they can become president - in theory, absolutely! In practice - not a chance in hell!
Simone - no hormones. Pissed off that I have to do the work of 3 people and I still don't get the respect I deserve! At least I don't have to go into an office! ;-)
Annoyed - women bosses are hands down the worst (except me, I am good! Ha ha!) This is because of that competitive thing. And you are right, they can't do every job, upper body strength and all...
Oh, and "isms" do suck. I can write a rant about each "ism" if I wanted to, which I don't.
Jenny - The reason I wrote this post is because this trying to do everything shite is just not working. Everyone is unhappy, the women, the kids, the husbands, everyone. Sage says they are doing all right. Maybe where he is standing but not from where I am.
"There are women who have no interest in having a career but find themselves in the new post-feminist society which has told them they are scum if they have no ambition in the business world."
to go along with this, what i see a lot of, in the community more than the workplace, is women who work bitching about women who don't, and vice versa. some mean venomous stuff.
Maybe the fact that the country you work in is changing dramatically with ongoing economic and cultural growing pains and that's what's causing some the problems with the culture. The family structure is suffering for it. Wasn't divorce just legalized there in the 1995?
Peace.
~ say hello to Cookie.
Hotwire - yup, I think women are turning on each other because of the pressure of trying to be too many things at one time.
Simone - nope. That's not it. I am actually thinking of my experiences in the US as well as here. And my job is run by England, not Ireland.
Post a Comment
<< Home